Five Myths of Christmas

Five Myths of Christmas

Join the Community!

The Wake-Up Call is a daily encouragement to shake off the slumber of our busy lives and turn our eyes toward Jesus.

Click here to get yours free in your inbox each morning!

So often we take traditions, songs, popular culture, or poems as what is true about Christmas.  One of my favorite parts of working with students this time of year is exposing them to the facts of the Christ’s birth that they think they know.  Too often we skim over or tune out Scripture that we’ve heard before and don’t dig deep enough to know what really happened.  Here are five common misconceptions to share with your students as we journey through Advent.

Myth 1: Jesus was born on December 25th.

Although it’s not impossible, it seems unlikely. The Bible does not specify a date or month. One problem with December is that Scripture tells us that the shepherds are living out in the fields (Luke 2:8).  The growing cycle for cereals in Israel starts in August and ripen in Spring. There is no way that farmers would allow grazing on their young plants through December.  It’s more likely that sheep are keeping the weeds controlled and fertilizing the fields after the Spring harvest.  Also, weather needed for growing grains in December would make the long distance travel from Nazareth to Bethlehem all the less enjoyable for the pregnant Mary. 

Myth 2: Three Kings brought gifts to Jesus on the night of his birth.

The Bible says magi came from the East, following a big star, and that they were looking for the King of the Jews. Magi are wise men, not kings, most believe the men were likely astrologers. These visitors are wealthy, as evident by their journey and gifts, and likely politically connected by their visit to Herod (Matthew 2:11). The number of and names of the magi are never detailed anywhere in writing. Since three gifts are listed in the Bible, scholars also say it’s possible that over time, people assumed this meant there were three men. They would have been traveling in a caravan to cover the distance and protect them and their gifts.

Further, the Bible says the men arrived when Jesus was a young child, not an infant, and they found him at home with his mom — not in a manger in a stable.  The magi did not arrive until sometime after Christ’s presentation in the Temple in Jerusalem (Luke 2:22-39).  It is possible that little Jesus was walking and talking by then and based on the calculations of King Herod and the magi (Matthew 2:16), Jesus could been two years old or under.

Myth 3: Jesus was born in a barn, stable, or cave.

The Bible does not mention any of these three places in connection with Christ’s birth, only a manger. Scripture simply reports that they laid Jesus in a manger because there was no room for him in the guest room. The Greek word used in Scripture is kataluma, and can mean guest chamber, lodging place or inn. The only other time this word was used in the New Testament, it means a furnished, large, upper story room within a private house. It is translated guest chamber, not inn (Mark 14:14-15). Jesus was probably born in the house of relatives, but outside (under) the normal living area and in guest quarters.  There may have been some animals around, as some animals were kept on this ground floor enclosure to protect them from the elements and theft.  It also provided body heat for cool nights, access to milk for meals and dung for cooking, which would also take place here.

Myth 4: Christians have always celebrated Christmas on December 25th.

The original significance of December 25 is that it was a well-known festival day celebrating the annual return of the sun. December 21 is the winter solstice and the 25th is the first day that ancients could clearly note that the days were definitely getting longer and the sunlight was returning.

So, why was December 25 chosen to remember Jesus Christ’s birth? Since no one knows the day of his birth, the Roman Catholic Church chose this date. They wanted to replace the pagan festival with a Christian holy day. It was easier to replace an unholy festival with a good one, than fight traditions.

Myth 5: The star of Bethlehem shone over the manger the night Jesus was born.

The star began to move slowly ahead of the wise men till it hovered over the place Jesus was located (Matthew 2:9).  This means that the star was not over the manger the night Jesus was born.  The star also shone over a house, possibly Joseph’s house back in Nazareth, and not a barn or inn (Matthew 2:11).  It is never called, “the star of Bethlehem”, but simply “his”or “the”star.


3 Responses

  1. Well done! One item though that you may wish to enhance: There is an ancient Talmudic tradition that a righteous man dies on the date of his conception. The early traditional date for the crucifixion was March 25th (around the Passover). Count nine months forward, and you have December 25th as the traditional birth date. This was the methodology followed by early Christians. We know from the writings of Hippolytus, that Christians were celebrating the birth of Christ on Dec. 25th as early as 204, and the pagan festival of Sol Invictus (Unconquered Sun), which was also celebrated on Dec. 25th, was created in 274. So actually, Christmas came first. There was a Roman festival called Saturnalia that pre-dates Christmas, but which ran from Dec. 17-23. Also, a minor point of clarification: Since we know from Hyppolytus that Christians were celebrating Christmas on Dec. 25th by 204 A.D., this date was established prior to the Great Schism between East and West in 1054, so technically there was no “Roman Catholic Church” at that time, it was still just the Church.
    Thanks for your ministry to young people, and for contributing to this great resource here on SeedBed.

  2. While Jesus was not likely born on December 25th, we don’t know for certain why December 25th was chosen to commemorate his birth or why Christians/the Catholic Church decided to make it an official Holiday in the 4th Century A.D. There is simply no historic record to this choice or action.

    It is speculated, as stated by the author, that December 25 was chosen to subsume the Roman holiday that commemorated the birth of the sun, but this is conjecture. The truth is the Winter Solstice was a popular holiday for many pagan religions and ancient cultures. Why shouldn’t the Christians choose this as a fitting day to commemorate Christ’s birth?

    And there is evidence that long before this day was officially chosen for the celebration, Christian scholars had recorded December 25 as the day of Christ’s birth; and also that some Christians had celebrated it on this day at least as early as the 3rd Century AD.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *