What Protestants Can Learn from Roman Catholics, Part 2

What Protestants Can Learn from Roman Catholics, Part 2

Join the Community!

The Wake-Up Call is a daily encouragement to shake off the slumber of our busy lives and turn our eyes toward Jesus.

Click here to get yours free in your inbox each morning!


Read Part 1 of this miniseries.

5. Mary Is Important

I was very apprehensive about the whole “Mary” subject. In an effort to avoid any type of Marian adoration or worship, the Protestants have left her behind. Sure, we may not want to go as far as meditating on a Hail Mary and putting her statue in our yards, but we should keep her example and her willingness to be the “handmaid of the Lord” at the forefront of our daily walk with the Lord. She could be called the very first disciple of Jesus (John 2). She knew what he could do and believed fully in Him.

The most important thing is to understand what Catholics actually believe about Mary. For more explanation on Mary, I would urge you to read a companion to the Catechism, like Catholic Christianity (Ignatius Press, 2001) by Peter Kreeft, or hear a great teaching by reformed Pastor and speaker, R.C. Sproul, on the topic, simply titled, “Mary.”

6. Prayer, Adoration and Reverence

After journeying for sometime in the Catholic Church, I’m realizing how much my prayer life has deepened. I feel that I can now sit in silence and solitude and not be uncomfortable. You may not understand the Rosary or be keen on the “Hail Mary” and “Hail Holy Queen” being uttered, but the purpose of meditation and contemplation behind the Rosary is beautiful.

The Catholic Church has a large list of prayers that can be lifted up to God, like the “Glory Be” and “Our Father,” but also beautifully worded prayers of meditation and reflection like “Divine Mercy Chaplet,” which simply asks the Lord to have mercy on the world.  Saint Ignatius’ Anima Christi prayer and some of Saint Francis’ prayers are among the scripted prayers that give us words we sometimes have trouble finding.

Among the Catholic attention to prayer, the reverence they have for the Lord and the Church is beautiful. Most churches have at least one 24-hour period a week where the Eucharist is exposed and people come and spend time with Jesus in Adoration of Him. Some churches even have 24/7 adoration.

At mass, they bow, they kneel, and they cross themselves. They respect the altar where communion is served and they treat church teaching and mass liturgy with respect and honor. There is incredible reverence and respect for how mighty and powerful, and how gracious and loving the Lord is. Everything has a purpose and everything has meaning. Each action and each phrase that is uttered means something and expresses something worshipful. Dr. Scott Hahn, a Protestant-turned-Catholic scholar and theologian has great teachings on the Mass in his books, like the Lamb’s Supper (Doubleday Religion, 1999) and his audio sermons like the “Fourth Cup.”

7. Confession Is Absolutely Necessary

This is a hot topic for debate among Protestants. Most think that Catholics believe that you have to confess your sins to a priest to be forgiven; you can’t just go straight to God. Confession is a necessary part of our faith. It keeps you accountable to someone and allows you to release things you have confessed to the Lord, but for which you may have a problem forgiving yourself. Paul warns us to keep our hearts clean when approaching communion. He says we reap judgment upon ourselves if we approach communion dishonorably.

8. Communion Is More than a Symbol

This was why I was drawn to the Catholic Church in the beginning. The church I was attending and the other churches I had visited treated communion like any ritual act and any other meal at church. There was no discussion of it’s true meaning; is it a symbol or does it mean something more? There was no call for repentance and confession before receiving the sacrament. There was no reverence for the thing Jesus specifically asked us to remember Him by.

This is not to say you have to believe in the “Real Presence” or transubstantiation. However, understand that communion, the bread and the wine, is much more than merely a symbol. John Wesley himself believed in the special graces the Sacrament affords its partakers. It is a sacred and intimate act with the Living God.

Many of the things the Catholic Church has taught for centuries have stood the test of time and are still influencing its practitioners and faithful believers. There is beauty in the tradition that influenced, at least in some way, the Protestant arena we live and work in today. What would it look like for us to be able to have unity with our Catholic brethren and be able to worship with them uninhibited? Surely there is significant work to be done by both traditions. As Paul says in 1 Corinthians 9, for the sake of the Gospel we should be “all things to all people.” In this way, we should embrace the richness that Catholic brothers and sisters bring to the Christian faith.

Visit our Worship Design Collective for more resources like this one.


3 Responses

  1. It seems misleading where you say “Most think that Catholics believe that you have to confess your sins to a
    priest to be forgiven; you can’t just go straight to God.”

    The Catholic teaching is that “1456
    Confession to a priest is an essential part of the sacrament of
    Penance: “All mortal sins of which penitents after a diligent
    self-examination are conscious must be recounted by them in confession,
    even if they are most secret and have been committed against the last
    two precepts of the Decalogue; for these sins sometimes wound the soul
    more grievously and are more dangerous than those which are committed

    Why do you have a deep love for Roman Catholicism Rebecca?
    was raised by Roman Catholics and there teaching and they teach that
    Jesus sinned when he was tempted by the devil and that Mary was the only
    sin free human ever because “how could Mary give birth to the savior if
    she had sin”.

    I am concerned where under your name it says
    Rebecca has a deep love for Roman Catholicism because RC is man made
    religion that can prevent salvation or cause people to fall from grace
    as it teaches that salvation is by works and faith/grace.

    also hold that anytime the teachings of the pope or Vatican contradict
    the scriptures then the church teachings hold more authority then

    1. I appreciate the things I’ve written about here and many other things. I’ve been attending Mass regularly for a few years now and have enjoyed the richness of the Christian faith outside of my own protestant tradition. My best friends growing up were Catholic, as well. I have a deep appreciate for my heritage and the heritage of my faith, with the Church Fathers and others who went before us. Sure, there are some things I’m working through to understand and even then, I may not agree with them all, but I can appreciate why they believe what they believe and I love seeing the broad spectrum of our faith. It truly is magnificent.

  2. Nic,

    When you talked about the Sacrament of Penance, you provided a link to back up your case.

    Yet, strangely, you did NOT provide any supporting link to your claim that Catholics believe that Jesus sinned (and that Mary is the only human that didn’t sin).

    Do you have any proof for this assertion?

    As a lifelong Catholic, I can assure you that your claim is a preposterous fabrication.

    I gladly await your proofs to the contrary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *